Many shavers feel stuck with harsh cartridges, ingrown hairs, and expensive refills, yet still want a close, traditional shave that actually feels relaxing. If that sounds familiar, a double edge safety razor might be exactly what you have been missing. Here are five standout options that users consistently rate highly:
Top double edge safety razors picked for a traditional shave
These are carefully selected based on user feedback, build quality, and how forgiving they are for real-world daily shaving, not just perfect barbershop conditions.
- THE PERFECT SHAVE: Make skin irritations and ingrown hair a problem of the past. With the double sided razor, you will achieve the closest shave effortlessly.
- THE SMOOTHEST SHAVE for both men & women – Significantly reducing ingrown hair, skin irritations and razor burn often experienced with plastic cartridge razors, helping you finally achieve the smoothest, cleanest and closest shave.
- THE PERFECT SHAVE: Make skin irritations and ingrown hair a problem of the past. With the black safety razor for men, you will achieve the closest shave effortlessly
- CLASSIC PRECISION: Classic edging precision for beard lines mastery including a closer shave, better control, and reduced skin irritation
- THE PLOW 2.0: The premium hygienic single blade safety razor that provides a close and comfortable shave like never before. We were so tired of trying to find the right tools for the job that we engineered our own.
Why choose a double edge safety razor at all
Before looking at handle lengths, blade gaps, and all the details, it helps to be clear about why you might switch in the first place. Otherwise the whole thing can start to feel like a hobby instead of a simple grooming choice.
For most people there are three main reasons:
Cost, comfort, and a more deliberate shaving experience.
A good double edge safety razor can turn shaving from a rushed chore into a short daily ritual that feels calmer and more controlled.
Cartridge systems lock you into specific blades that are usually expensive. With a safety razor, blades are cheap and interchangeable. You are free to try different brands until you find the one that matches your skin and hair type.
Comfort is the other side. Many users who struggle with razor burn and ingrown hairs find that using a single, sharp double edge blade with proper technique is far kinder on the skin than dragging 3 or 5 cartridge blades across the same patch over and over.
How a double edge safety razor actually works
The concept is simple. A thin blade sits between two metal plates, with only the edge exposed. The top cap and base plate screw into the handle. When you tighten the handle, the blade bends slightly, which affects how it cuts.
Two details matter most for how the razor feels on your face:
Blade exposure
This is how far the blade sticks out beyond the safety bar or comb.
-
Neutral or low exposure: usually gentler, better for beginners and sensitive skin.
-
Positive exposure: more blade feels, more cutting power, but higher risk of nicks if technique is poor.
Blade gap
This is the space between the blade edge and the safety bar or comb. A larger gap tends to feel more aggressive and removes more hair with each stroke.
There is no official standard for what is “mild” or “aggressive” because skin types and shaving angles differ so much. That is why adjustable razors exist, which we will get into in a moment.
Main types of double edge safety razors
The design of the head and handle influences control, comfort, and ease of cleaning. Understanding these types helps you match a razor to your habits instead of guessing.
Closed comb vs open comb
This is one of the first choices someone new to traditional shaving will face.
Closed comb razors have a solid safety bar in front of the blade, sometimes with small grooves. They feel smoother on the skin and are usually better for daily shaving.
Open comb razors have visible teeth in front of the blade. These guide longer hair to the blade and are popular with people who shave every few days or have very thick stubble.
For a first safety razor, a mild or medium closed comb design is usually the safest and most forgiving place to start.
Three-piece, two-piece, and butterfly
The way a razor loads blades affects maintenance and convenience more than shaving performance, but it still matters.
Three-piece
-
Separate handle, base plate, and top cap
-
Very easy to clean
-
Common design, often with many compatible aftermarket handles
Two-piece
-
Handle and base plate are attached, top cap comes off
-
Faster blade changes than three-piece
-
Still easy to wash out lather and hair
Butterfly (twist-to-open)
-
Top of the razor opens like doors when you twist the knob
-
Very quick blade changes
-
Can be harder to deep clean inside the mechanism over time
For someone who cares about long term durability and simple cleaning, a three-piece design is often preferred. For those who want speed and convenience, a butterfly design can feel nicer, especially if eyesight or hand strength is not perfect.
Adjustable vs fixed head
This is where things can get a bit more technical, but in practice it is not as complex as it sounds.
Fixed head razors have one blade gap and exposure. The shave feel does not change unless you swap blades or adjust your technique.
Adjustable razors let you change the blade gap, and sometimes exposure, with a dial or setting system. Low settings feel mild, high settings feel more aggressive.
Who might prefer each?
-
Fixed head: users who want a predictable shave without decisions every morning.
-
Adjustable: users who like to change settings for different passes, or share a razor in a household with different beard types.
What to look for when choosing a double edge safety razor
Shaving forums often turn this into a complex subject, but the real decision comes down to a few main points: beard type, skin sensitivity, weight, and balance.
Match the razor to your hair and skin
This is more important than brand names or shiny finishes.
| Beard / Skin Type | Razor Traits That Help |
|---|---|
| Light beard, sensitive skin | Mild closed comb, low blade exposure, lighter weight |
| Average beard, normal skin | Medium aggression closed comb, medium weight |
| Thick or wiry beard | Medium to high aggression, or adjustable set higher, heavier handle |
| Shaves every few days | Open comb or slightly more aggressive closed comb |
If you do not know where you fit, it is safer to start mild and pair the razor with a sharp blade. A forgiving razor with a sharp blade often beats a very aggressive razor with a duller one.
Weight and handle length
Weight affects how much pressure you naturally apply. Heavier razors encourage you to let the razor do the work, which many users find improves technique.
-
Short handles feel more nimble, good if you like choking up near the head for more control.
-
Long handles give more leverage and may feel better for those with large hands or when shaving the body, not just the face.
There is no universal “best” handle length. If you tend to hold a pen closer to the tip, you may like a shorter handle. If you grip often at the center or back, a longer one might feel more natural.
Grip and handle texture
A good safety razor should not feel slippery when your hands are covered in lather. Knurling patterns on the handle help with that.
A deep, consistent grip pattern can matter more in daily use than tiny differences in blade gap or head shape.
When comparing razors, pay close attention to the handle texture. Smooth chrome looks nice in photos but can be hard to keep steady in a wet bathroom.
Material and build quality
Most modern double edge razors fall into a few material categories:
-
Zinc alloy with plating: common, usually affordable, good enough for many users if cared for.
-
Stainless steel: more durable, more weight, often higher price.
-
Brass: solid feel, can develop patina if not plated and polished.
Stainless steel and brass often appeal to users who want a razor that will last for many years without wearing down. Zinc alloy razors can last a long time too if they are not dropped and the plating stays intact, but they are generally seen as entry level or midrange options.
How head design affects your shave
Two razors that look similar can shave very differently. The curves and angles in the head design guide your hand and influence the “ideal” shaving angle.
Top cap shape and shaving angle
When you place the razor on your skin, you usually rock it slightly until the blade engages. A good design makes the right angle feel natural, without conscious effort.
Some heads are flatter, which tends to help those who like a shallow angle, almost riding the cap. Others have more curved caps, which can encourage a steeper angle closer to the safety bar.
If you find yourself constantly guessing the angle or missing patches of stubble, the head geometry may not suit your natural shaving style.
Comb design and lather flow
The space under the blade needs to channel lather and cut hair away during the stroke. Tight or poorly shaped channels can clog, especially if your lather is thick or your hair is long.
Look for razors that users describe as easy to rinse. That feedback often tells you more about real shaving performance than marketing language about “precision engineering.”
Pros and cons of using a double edge safety razor
No tool is perfect. Some users fall in love with traditional shaving, others try it and go back to cartridges. Being honest about both sides helps you decide without regret.
Where double edge razors really shine
-
Blades are usually far cheaper per use than cartridge refills.
-
Only one blade touches your skin at a time, which can reduce irritation.
-
Greater control over how aggressive or gentle the shave feels.
-
Wide choice of blades to match sensitive skin or tough stubble.
-
Metal construction often feels more solid and lasts longer than plastic.
-
Less plastic waste than multi-blade cartridges.
-
Can reach tight spots like under the nose more easily.
-
Encourages better prep and technique, which often improves skin condition.
Real drawbacks and annoyances
-
Learning curve: early shaves can include nicks while you adjust technique.
-
Shaving takes a bit more time and attention than quick cartridge passes.
-
Travel can be trickier because loose blades are not allowed in some hand luggage.
-
Choice overload: many blade and razor combinations can feel confusing.
-
Some razors can feel too aggressive for beginners, leading to frustration.
-
Blade disposal needs a safe system instead of just tossing in the bin loose.
-
Partners or family members might not like sharing bathroom space with many blades and soaps at first.
How to choose the right blade for your safety razor
The razor is only half the equation. Blades vary a lot in sharpness, smoothness, and coating. The same blade that feels perfect in one razor can feel harsh in another.
A simple approach works best.
Start with a sampler pack of blades, keep notes for a week or two, and pay attention to comfort on the second and third shave with each blade.
Some blades feel amazing on the first shave but drop off fast. Others feel average on the first pass and then smooth out on the second shave. Your skin may respond differently from someone else with similar beard thickness.
When testing blades:
-
Change only one variable at a time. Keep the same razor and soap while you try new blades.
-
Use each blade for at least two shaves before judging.
-
Note not just closeness, but post shave feel over the next few hours.
Technique tips for a traditional safety razor shave
Even the best razor will feel rough if used with cartridge habits. The key differences are pressure, angle, and passes.
Preparation matters more than you think
Soften the beard and cleanse the skin first. Some users shave after a warm shower, others use a hot towel. A simple face wash with warm water and a gentle cleanser can also help remove oils that block water from entering the hair shaft.
A good lather with a brush helps too. It lifts the hairs and creates a slick surface so the blade can glide. Canned foam can work in a pinch, but a quality soap or cream with a brush often leads to less drag and fewer skips.
Pressure and passes
Let the weight of the razor work. That sentence can sound like a cliché, but it matters. Pressing down hard to “get closer” usually just removes more skin cells and creates burn.
-
Use short strokes, especially around the jawline and chin.
-
Keep the skin as flat as possible by stretching gently with your free hand.
-
Shave first with the grain, then across, and only consider against the grain if your skin tolerates it well.
If you feel tugging, either the blade is dull, the angle is off, or the lather is too dry. Adjust one element and see if the feel changes.
Maintenance and care for your safety razor
A double edge razor is a precision tool, but caring for it is not complicated.
Daily care
-
Rinse the head under warm water during the shave to prevent clogging.
-
After shaving, open the head slightly and rinse away soap residue.
-
Gently shake off water and let the razor air dry in a stand or on a towel.
Wiping the razor aggressively with a towel can damage the blade edge, so try not to rub the head on cloth while the blade is installed.
Occasional deeper cleaning
-
Disassemble the razor and soak metal parts in warm soapy water.
-
Use a soft toothbrush around threads and grooves.
-
Rinse well and dry fully before reassembling.
If your water is hard, mineral spots can appear over time. A gentle wipe with a cloth after drying usually manages this. Harsh chemicals are not needed and can damage plating.
Quick buyer guide checklist
When comparing double edge safety razors, this simple checklist can keep things clear:
-
Is the razor closed comb or open comb, and how often do you shave?
-
Is the head adjustable or fixed, and do you really want to adjust settings every time?
-
How long and heavy is the handle, and does that match your grip style?
-
Is the handle knurled enough to feel secure when wet?
-
What is the main material: zinc alloy, stainless steel, or brass?
-
Does the design make blade alignment easy and obvious?
-
Are replacement blades easily available where you live?
-
Do real users describe it as mild, medium, or aggressive, and how does that match your skin and hair?
Common mistakes new safety razor users make
Quite a few people give up on traditional shaving after a week or two, often for reasons that are easy to avoid.
-
Using too much pressure, as with a cartridge.
-
Chasing a perfectly smooth result in one pass instead of using multiple gentle passes.
-
Using a very aggressive razor and very sharp blade at the same time on sensitive skin.
-
Not hydrating the beard long enough before shaving.
-
Skipping post shave care, then blaming the razor for dryness or irritation.
-
Switching blades and soaps constantly, so it is impossible to know what is helping or hurting.
If the first week feels rough, do not assume a safety razor is not for you. Often a small change in blade, angle, or pressure makes a surprisingly big difference.
FAQ about double edge safety razors for a traditional shave
Are double edge safety razors better than cartridges for a traditional shave?
They can be, but “better” depends on your priorities. For many users, double edge razors give a closer shave with less irritation and far lower long term cost. For others who value speed above all, cartridges still win. If you like a slower, more traditional shave, double edge razors tend to feel more satisfying.
Which double edge safety razor aggression level is best for beginners?
A mild to medium aggression level is usually best at the start. Very mild razors can require more passes, which some users do not like, while very aggressive razors punish small mistakes. Something in the middle, paired with a decent blade, offers a good balance of comfort and closeness.
How often should blades be changed in a double edge safety razor?
Most people change blades after 3 to 7 shaves. Coarse beards may need more frequent changes, while light beards can stretch a blade longer. If you feel tugging, increased resistance, or see more redness than usual, it is time for a fresh blade.
Are double edge safety razors safe for sensitive skin?
Yes, many people with sensitive skin prefer them. The key is choosing a mild razor, a smooth blade, and focusing on light pressure and good lather. Multiple gentle passes often irritate less than forcing a close shave in one harsh pass with a cartridge.
Can a double edge safety razor be used for body shaving?
Yes, many users shave body hair with safety razors. A longer handle and good grip help when reaching awkward areas. Take extra care with pressure, especially on curved parts of the body. A mild razor is usually safer here, even if you use a more aggressive one on the face.
What is the difference between a closed comb and open comb double edge safety razor for a traditional shave?
A closed comb razor has a solid safety bar and feels smoother and more protective on the skin. It suits daily or near daily shaving. An open comb has teeth that expose the blade more and handle longer or thicker growth better, but can feel a bit more aggressive for some users.
Do double edge safety razors really save money?
In most cases, yes. Once you own the razor, blades are usually inexpensive. The savings become clear over time, especially if you were using name brand cartridge systems before. The only catch is that some users start collecting razors, which can turn shaving back into a hobby expense.
How should double edge safety razor blades be disposed of safely?
Use a simple blade bank or any sturdy metal container with a slot. Drop used blades inside and seal the container only when full. Many people repurpose a small tin. This protects you and anyone handling the trash from accidental cuts.
So is a double edge safety razor right for you?
If you want a traditional shave that feels calmer, gives more control, and cuts down on long term costs, a double edge safety razor is worth a serious try. The first week may involve a few nicks and a bit of learning, but many users find that once technique settles, the shave feels closer, kinder to the skin, and more intentional than what they were used to.
The real question is simple: are you willing to slow down a little and learn a new tool for a few shaves, in exchange for that kind of control and comfort? If the answer is yes, then a well chosen safety razor, matched to your beard and skin, will probably earn a permanent spot on your bathroom shelf.